• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Contact our Team
  • In the News
  • For NYC Residents
    • NYC Free Parking Calendar 2020
    • ID NYC Card for Free Museum Admission
    • Where to Donate Goods or Volunteer

NYC on the Cheap

Get More New York City for Less Money

  • Aways
    Free
    • Best FREE Things to Do in New York City
    • FREE Museum Admission by Borough
    • FREE Museum Admission by Day of Week
    • NYC Museums With No Admission Fee Ever
    • FREE Tickets to Late Night TV Shows
    • FREE Tickets to Daytime TV Shows
  • Entertainment
    & the Arts
    • Family Fun
    • NYC Discount Tickets
    • Philadelphia Ticket Deals
    • Movies
    • NYC Free: Museum Admission by Day of Week
    • NYC Theater
  • Food & Drink
    Deals
    • Where to Eat in Times Square
    • Best Jewish delis for overstuffed sandwiches
    • All-You-Can-Eat Sushi Deals
    • Best NYC Lobster Restaurants
    • Best Happy Hours
    • Birthday Freebies: Restaurants
    • Daily Deals
  • Shopping
    in NYC
    • Ten Things for $1 in NYC
    • Scam Alert
    • Discounts for Seniors
    • Birthday Freebies: Retail Stores
    • Best Resale Shops
    • Cheapest Gas
  • Things
    to Do
    • Seasonal Events
    • Free & Cheap Weekend Events
    • NYC Historic Homes now Museums
    • Where to See Hamilton in NYC
    • NYC Theater
    • Carousels in All 5 Boros
    • 9/11 Memorial & Museum
    • Events in NYC Parks
    • Get Free Tickets to Late Night TV Shows
    • NYC Festivals
    • Getting Around
  • Family
    Fun
    • Best Musems for Kids in Manhattan
    • Carousels in all 5 Boroughs
  • Crisis
    Resources
  • Scam
    Alert
  • Getaways
    & Travel Deals
  • Free & Cheap
    Events
  • Best FREE Things to Do in NYC
  • NYC Sightseeing and Tours Discounts
  • Ticket Deals
  • Cheapest Gas Prices
  • For NYC Residents
You are here: Home / Brooklyn / NYC cheap eats: Gumbo Bros. Cajun food in Brooklyn
← NYC free: Citizenship Test prep at NYPL
NYC free: Valentine Hearts in Times Square →

NYC cheap eats: Gumbo Bros. Cajun food in Brooklyn

POSTED BY
Evelyn Kanter

nyc cheap eats: gumbo bros.The Big Easy has arrived in Brooklyn at the new Gumbo Bros. in Brooklyn, serving Cajun food at prices more suitable to Lousiana and Alabama, where the restaurant partners are from, than NYC prices.  Menu items start at $4, and the most expensive thing on the menu is just $14.

Recommended Dishes: Cajun chicken and sausage gumbo; roast beef po’ boy; rice and debris gravy; braised greens; fried green tomatoes with reémoulade; mini bourbon pecan pie; beignets.

Here’s what restaurant review Ligaya Michan says about Gumbo Bros. in the New York Times:

SEE ALSO Mardi Gras Crawfish Boil free tickets

 Adam Lathan, the chef of the Gumbo Bros, lays no claim to the one true gumbo. “I can’t make it like your grandmother did,” he said apologetically. “I’ll try my best.”

The restaurant is in Boerum Hill, but its red sign was painted by hand on Magazine Street in New Orleans. Inside, a golden football helmet with a fleur-de-lis overlooks portraits of Napoleon, hand thrust inside waistcoat, and the blues pianist James Booker, called the Bayou Maharajah, in eye patch and halo.

The menu is lit on a marquee, with bags of Zapp’s Voodoo Potato Chips dangling below. Diners drink Abita root beer or coffee brewed with chicory, tasting of roasted earth. Each table is set with Crystal hot sauce, whose ingredient list puts cayenne where it should be: first.

Mr. Lathan grew up on the Gulf Coast of Alabama, in Creole country; his business partner, Clay Boulware, comes from Cajun central Louisiana. Once roommates at Louisiana State University, they reunited in New York a few years ago to redress the city’s scarcity of gumbo, selling the dish at outdoor food markets before opening the restaurant in early December.

Some say gumbo is less learned than inherited. Mr. Lathan got his starter recipe from his great-grandmother Nanny, who passed it down to his father. It begins with a roux of canola oil and flour cooked just short of total darkness and fused with onion, celery and bell pepper.

His Cajun gumbo speaks in smoke, leached from andouille sausage made by a Louisiana butcher. The meat is browned until its edges crisp, then wedded with chicken poached in house-made bone stock. Broken-down okra helps thicken it, so much that it almost tugs back the spoon. The result is dense and warming, though some might wish for more fire.

For a Creole version, Mr. Lathan bypasses the tomatoes that sometimes divide it from its Cajun cousin. He relies instead on the sweetness of shrimp and blue crabs, which he gets live from Chinatown and coaxes into a stock meant to taste “like you’re at a crab boil,” he said.

The dominant note is filé, ground sassafras leaves, which lends a flavor somewhere between root beer and camphor. I found it too strong, but for a friend from Louisiana, it was the taste that made him nod and say, “This.”

A vegan gumbo aroused suspicions (“Oxymoron,” my Louisiana friend said) but turned out to be a Louisianian Roman Catholic tradition during Lent. It’s made of as many greens as Mr. Lathan can get his hands on and thickened with only okra, no roux.

To me, it had a slight must from an over-suffusion of sage. Perhaps there is always quibbling when it comes to gumbo.

On the wall hangs a message dating to the New Orleans 1929 streetcar workers’ strike, when the Martin brothers, who ran a coffee stand in the French Market, told the strikers, “We are with you till h—l freezes, and when it does, we will furnish blankets to keep you warm.” They also provided giant sandwiches that became known as po’ boys.

Here the po’ boys are made with loaves from Leidenheimer Baking Company in New Orleans, which have crusts as thin as the skin of a balloon, ready to fracture. They are swabbed with Duke’s mayo, which eschews sugar for a more pronounced tang, and lined with tomatoes and pickles.

My first encounter went poorly. The bread was stiff and underdressed, the batter on the fried shrimp and catfish seemingly bereft of spice. But the next time, they were glories.

Best is one packed with roast beef, a beautiful sopping mess of Black Angus chuck, marinated in root beer and roasted for 16 hours. The remains of the mirepoix it is cooked with are puréed and added to the drippings to make debris gravy, which — alone — might be worth pawning your soul for.

There are a few commendable sides: greens smoky-sweet from courting ham hocks and bacon, and fried green tomatoes crackly with bread crumbs from leftover Leidenheimer loaves. A Cajun potato salad had little presence, but I wondered if the point was to add it to the gumbo, as some Louisianians do.

If, after all this, dessert is still required, tiny bourbon pecan pies are fine specimens (another Nanny recipe). Beignets are rough, snowed under with confectioners’ sugar, crunchy on the outside and chewy within. They puzzled the people at my table, who expected airy balls of dough.

So reviewer Mishan ate theirs.

Recommended Dishes: Cajun chicken and sausage gumbo; roast beef po’ boy; rice and debris gravy; braised greens; fried green tomatoes with reémoulade; mini bourbon pecan pie; beignets. Prices: $4 to $14.

 The Gumbo Bros.
  • 224 Atlantic Avenue (Court Street), Boerum Hill, 917-909-1471.  Reservations not accepted.

As much as we’d like to, NYC on the Cheap can’t eat everywhere, so we’ll be publishing occasional reviews of inexpensive new restaurants by restaurant reviewers we trust, including the New York Times, New York Magazine and Time Out New York.

If you like this idea, add a comment below.

 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Related

Posted by Evelyn Kanter on February 7, 2017 | Updated February 7, 2017 Filed Under: Brooklyn · Cheap Eats

Reader Interactions

What do you think about this? We welcome your comments. Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Get Free Email Updates

Be the first to know about NYC free and cheap events, discounts and deals by signing up for our FREE enewsletter.

Latest News Trending Now

  • NYC Movie Theaters Re-Open on Friday, March 5
    NYC Movie Theaters Re-Open on Friday, March 5
  • Van Gogh Immersive 360-Degree Exhibit Experience Tickets Now on Sale
    Van Gogh Immersive 360-Degree Exhibit Experience Tickets Now on Sale
  • 101 FREE & Cheap Things to Do This Week March 1-7
    101 FREE & Cheap Things to Do This Week March 1-7
  • Frick Madison Opens March 18; Tickets on Sale
    Frick Madison Opens March 18; Tickets on Sale
  • Dolly Parton 75th Birthday Celebration is Online & FREE
    Dolly Parton 75th Birthday Celebration is Online & FREE
  • Boycotting Goya Products? Try These Authentic Alternatives
    Boycotting Goya Products? Try These Authentic Alternatives
  • Fast Food Deals & Discounts for March
    Fast Food Deals & Discounts for March
  • 5 Best All You Can Eat Sushi Deals in NYC
    5 Best All You Can Eat Sushi Deals in NYC
  • NYC Free: Document Shredding
    NYC Free: Document Shredding
  • In the Heights Movie Version June 2021 Release
    In the Heights Movie Version June 2021 Release

Search by Category

Footer

About NYC on the Cheap

NYC does not have to be expensive when you know where the deals and freebies are.

We’re here to help you save money on NYC restaurants, theater, museums, shopping, events and more, as we have been doing since 2010.

Get more NYC for less money with NYCOTC. That’s our motto and we’re sticking to it.

Contact us: info@nyconthecheap.com

Who We Are

Your chief guide is Evelyn Kanter, a lifelong New Yorker and award-winning professional journalist.

Evelyn Kanter is a former consumer reporter for WABC-TV Eyewitness News and WCBS Radio Newsradio 88, the author of several NYC travel guidebooks and mobile apps, and zillions of newspaper and magazine articles, including for the NY Times, NY Post, NY Daily News and New York Magazine. Nobody  can match those NYC credentials.

Disclosure

NYC on the Cheap has an affiliate relationship with several companies which offer discounts and deals on this site.  When you purchase from one of these advertiser links, we earn a small commission.

If you’d like to help keep NYCOTC in the business of helping you save money, this is a great way to do it. It’s a win-win because the direct links save you both time searching for great deals and money.

Best Seller: NYC Guidebook by Evelyn Kanter

100 Things to do in NYC Before You Die

© 2021 NYC on the Cheap. Living On The Cheap® and On the Cheap® are registered trademarks owned by Living On The Cheap Inc. Site design by Five J's Design.
All the stories on our site are protected by copyright and any unauthorized copying is strictly prohibited. Plus, it is just not nice.

Email subscription form header
Subscribe for free to NYC on the Cheap and never miss a free event or discount deal.
Our daily newsletter is the FREE. fast. and easy way to find out about New York City deals, discounts, free events, and more.
Please wait...
Please enter all required fields Click to hide
Correct invalid entries Click to hide
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.